This is even as the 12-year average indicator value for India stands at only 79 level, suggesting the domestic stocks are overvalued. It is because if there is a correction in the market, new investors would surely lose the money. But, the investors who exited from the market would try to enter at some level. In fact, during the market crash in Mar 2020 when Nifty fell down to 7600 due to COVID, many investors didn’t invest their money thinking that Nifty would touch 6000.
Hence, their growth at valuations exceeding GDP growth is not counted in the Buffet Indicator. Indian equity markets were trading firmly in green on Wednesday. While Sensex reclaimed 60,000, Nifty 50 climbed above 17,900. Amid the recent rally, investors are looking to enter the stock market to take advantage of the bull momentum. For all those who are confused when to buy stocks, Zerodha co-founder Nikhil Kamath shared some advice on Twitter.
Q. How do you interpret a Buffett Indicator?
Here’s why hundreds of thousands of readers spread across more than 70 countries Trust Equitymaster. What explains the divergence in the realty sector when home sales fell sharply in the December quarter? As per property consultant Knight Frank, home sales across eight major cities fell by 41% to 40,936 units whereas launches slumped by 61% to 24,316 units. Most likely construction and realty firms, riding on an anticipated pick-up in demand, did not shelve projects in the December quarter. Home buyers, in the meantime, may have to still wait for a steep correction in house prices even as banks have cut interest rates sharply to kick-start demand.
With headline index Nifty having dropped around 6% from its 52-week high level of 18,888, India’s market capitalisation-to-GDP ratio, also known as the Buffett Indicator, has now dropped well below the 100% mark. Since 1996, Equitymaster has been the source for honest and credible opinions on investing in India. With solid research and in-depth analysis Equitymaster is dedicated towards making its readers- smarter, more confident and richer every day.
But, there is still a lot of dependence on foreign investment. Still, it’s worth noting that Buffett’s preferred gauge has its flaws. For example, it compares the stock market’s current value with a GDP reading from several months ago. GDP also excludes overseas income, whereas US companies’ market caps reflect the value of both their domestic and foreign operations. It is significant to emphasise that, of course, no single indicator can represent the entire market. The Buffett Indicator is criticised for not taking into account the condition of non-equity asset markets when used as a valuation indicator.
At 3.4 times, Nifty’s 12-month trailing PBV was above its historical average of 2.9 times – at a 18 per cent premium. Bond-earnings yield ratio or BEER ratio suggests the attractiveness of equities against bonds. If the ratio is below 1, equity investments are deemed inexpensive, attractive.
However, the Buffett indicator has some limitations when it comes to the Indian market.
Assessment of market valuation through the Nifty PE ratio or market cap to GDP would become totally meaningless at that point in time. They will pull money when there will be an increase in interest rates from the US Fed. US fed would eventually increase the interest rate when the inflation would increase due to high liquidity. When there will be an increase in interest rates, there will be a crunch of liquidity in the market.
It’s a way of measuring the worth of something, which is the equity market if you’re reading this blog. Amit Kumar Gupta has over 15 yrs of experience in investment analysis and portfolio management. Phillip Capital in a strategy note said it has a ‘Neutral’ stance on Indian equities. Downside risk will open, it said, as global monetary tightening continues, triggering global growth slowdown.
Digital payments have received a leg-up post demonetisation and this is likely to aid in the growth of e-commerce. But internet companies need to focus on improving their profitability if they have to survive and thrive in this industry. I hope this article would help you understand how to identify if the markets are overvalued and what is the reason for this overvaluation and what should be the right strategy to balance the overall portfolio.
But as per the capex data from the Centre for Monitoring Indian Economy, the construction and real estate sector has outperformed most of the other sectors in the December 2016 quarter. In fact, the sector witnessed new projects valued at Rs 90 billion, more than double than that announced in the year-ago quarter and nearly three folds as compared to the preceding September 2016 quarter. Even the share of stalled projects in overall projects has declined from 10.2% in September 2016 quarter to 10.1% in December 2016 quarter. However, over the long run, it is the fundamental value that drives the stock. The long term average Market cap to GDP ratio for the Indian markets since 2002 stands at 60 percent. This ratio currently stands at 65 percent, though higher than the long term average.
Share this Comment:
He’s worked for the International Business Times, The Inquisitr, and Moneycontrol in the past. He’s also contributed to Free Press Journal and TheRichest with feature articles. He covers news for a wide range of subjects including business, finance, economy, politics and social media.
- When there will be an increase in interest rates, there will be a crunch of liquidity in the market.
- So, these companies are a big part of the GDP but not accounted for in the market capitalization calculation and that causes some imbalances in the Buffett Indicator.
- Despite some recent corrections in the wake of the Russia-Ukraine crisis, Indian equities remain expensive and markets remain overvalued.
- While earnings growth has been robust so far, valuations are not cheap.
- The Buffett Indicator is used to find out whether a country’s stock market is fairly valued.
- With 60% of equities trading at a premium to their historical averages, it is no surprise that the market cap-to-GDP ratio at 115% is way above the long-term average of 79%.
They know that the markets are overvalued and hence they have not invested into the market or completely exited from the market with a hope that the market will correct in the future and they will reinvest. 1st set of people are those who are relatively new investors and entered into the stock market after the recent rally. They are highly optimistic people and have invested all their money into the stock market. Probably because they haven’t seen any bear market or never witnessed stock market crash. This is the Warren Buffett Indicator, the total market cap relative to the US gross domestic product . For the market cap typically the Wilshire 5000 total market cap is used, which is representing the value of all stocks traded in the United States.
This Warren Buffett valuation indicator is flashing red for Indian equities
Buying stocks would be “likely to work very well” at a 70% or 80% level, but would be “playing with fire” around the 200% mark, he wrote. Analysts say, this signals rich valuation of Indian stocks, but most likely factors in a recovery in the near future given the pandemic-led slowdown in India’s economic growth. If you’re here for the first time, don’t forget to check out “Free Training” section where we have tons of free videos and articles to kick start your stock market journey. And finally, the majority are small and medium scale industries , whose output is counted in the GDP but are not listed on the stock exchanges and hence their valuations are not accounted for in the Buffett indicator. Thus, it’s best to use the market cap to GDP ratio with other economic indicators to ensure that you’re making an informed decision.
Just for reference, the total stock market capitalization includes all publicly-traded companies. Oflate, there is a significant inflow of FII money in the Indian stock market. This is mainly due to huge amount of liquidity in the US market as the US Fed has printed Trillions of US dollars. This has resulted in a lot of liquidity and the fact that the US Fed has reduced the interest rate significantly. Governments use this interest rate to accelerate the economy or put a brake on it.
Nifty is currently trading at 12-month trailing PE at 21.5x, 7% higher than its long-term average of 20x. On a 12-month forward PE basis, the index is currently trading at 17.7x which is below its average of 18.4x. While there is no consensus on this, stocks are often deemed expensive when the value climbs above 100 level. In FY21, the Buffett Indicator, named after legendary investor Warren Buffett, stood at 104% while in FY22 the figure stood at 112%. However, the indicator remains much above its long-term average of about 79%. In such a market, thoroughly analysing every business and making selective stock bets is an approach that will help one make outsized returns.
India’s Latest Market Cap to GDP Ratio Introduction In the current Equity market outlook, India’s Market Cap to GDP ratio… Secondly, instead of purely relying on this indicator, if you use it along with other valuation metrics such as Price to Earnings, you would get a more reliable picture of the Indian economy. All this means is that although the Buffett indicator might be very reliable for western countries where the primary markets are well developed, it is still imperfect in developing countries like India. Furthermore, the Buffett Indicator is known as many things – an economic indicator, a valuation technique, and others. As D-Street stands weeks from the New Year, Indian equity benchmarks have often shied away from inches within their all-time highs of October 2021 during much of 2022. Prabhudas remains overweight on auto, banks, IT services, capital goods and healthcare.
What do you think would happen to the overall market’s valuation? For example, a giant public listing has the potential to tilt the indicator’s value. Imagine this – a company with a trillion-dollar valuation listing in the public market for the first time. Before we talk about the Buffett Indicator, you must’ve heard the term “valuation”.
Dividend Paying Stocks In May 2023
For example, due to COVID, there were a lot of job losses, so the US fed lowered interest rates to as low as 0.25% so that businesses can borrow money at a cheaper rate and generate employment. Also consumers can borrow money at lower rates and spend more. So both factors including trillions of dollars of stimulus and lower interest rates have resulted in a huge inflow of money in Indian market and this has resulted in increase of share price in India.
So India is a big market for US investors as they invest a lot of money via FII or Foreign Institutional Investment. Hence, Indian stock market movement depends a lot on foreign investment. Although, today we also have domestic institutional investors that also impact the stock market movement.
So, these companies are a big part of the GDP but not accounted for in the market capitalization calculation and that causes some imbalances in the Buffett Indicator. To give you a better sense, this is how the Buffett indicator has looked like for the Indian stock market from 2007 to 2018. If you notice the two times the indicator spiked, in 2007 and 2017, the market saw some significant correction. It’s an indicator that Warren Buffett uses to get an overall feel of the valuation of the US stocks- whether they are undervalued or overvalued and it’s pretty easy to calculate. In fact, you’d witness the same situation if you used the market cap to GDP ratio when Aramco was listed in Saudi Arabia.
Additionally, the size of privately owned, unlisted companies has grown dramatically. This percentage is far greater than the current data could indicate when you take into account the projected market value of companies like Vodafone, Paytm etc. These indicators are quantifiable and aim to foretell market movements by interpreting financial or stock index data. Technical indicators are divided into market indicators, which are frequently composed of formulae and ratios. They support traders’ and investors’ investing decisions while online trading. After opening in the green, Indian equity markets have been on an uptrend.
Taper talks in the US, potentially higher US bond yields and dollar, consensus buffett indicator india per share cuts, recent muted IPO gains hurting retail investor sentiment could act as negative triggers, they said in a report on 20 August. India’s equity valuations measured using market capitalisation-to gross domestic product ratio have risen significantly above their historical average. India’s GDP growth is poised for a recovery but the robust rally in Indian stock markets could keep this ratio at elevated levels. Delayed revival in corporate earnings and a potential third wave remain keys risks to the ongoing up move in Indian stocks, analysts said. The stock market of India, much like the stock market of many other countries, is a complex and not easily evaluated.
Other flaws include the lack of accounting for interest rate changes. This was pretty much the case in most markets, including the US which had a Buffett Value of ~194%. But then COVID hit in 2020 and a lot of new investors entered the market. Let’s see whether this pushed the Indian market to be fairly valued or overvalued. But the stock market isn’t a sandwich – it’s vast and diverse with companies from sectors like finance, pharma, and others. Market indicators combine a number of data elements with a statistically derived formula to arrive at a conclusion.
It is significant to emphasise that, of course, no one indicator can represent the whole market. The Buffett Indicator’s absence of a focus on markets that deal with non-equity assets is its main drawback as a market indicator. While online trading investors must really take into account and examine a wide range of asset types. The majority of indicators developed in the stock market today are developed by examining the market breadth, or the ratio of businesses making new highs to new lows, as it indicates the direction of the general trend. Another popular kind of indicator is one where the overall sentiment that is prevalent in the market during a given period of time is evaluated. To appropriately evalute and inturn make investment decisions regarding the stock market today, most investors make use of certain indicators.
Besides, in the last 12 months, the global market cap has declined 8.4 per cent while on the contrary India’s market cap has risen 7.4 per cent. Barring Indonesia and India, all key global markets saw a decline in market cap over the last 12 months. According to the chart, the ratio for India’s FY23 stands at 103%, which indicates that the market is now overvalued.
Before working with digital news publications, he worked as a freelance content writer. Despite the fact that the future cannot be anticipated, it is easy to look at historical data to see how the market has performed after periods of high and low value for the Buffett Indicator. Furthermore, corporate profits are often correlated with GDP growth.